PeaceBang
The manic mind of the minister -- Auntie Mame Meets Cotton Mather. Blogging about Unitarian Universalism, UU Christian spiritual practice, occasional cultural and political ravings, and the inner life of ministry. PeaceBang is the alter ego of a small town pastor serving an historic New England Unitarian Universalist congregation.
Take This Bread: A PeaceBang Review
September 29, 2007 on 5:54 am | In Inspirations, Shout-Outs, TV/Movies/Theatre/Book Reviews |Sara Miles is a fan of this blog and wrote me a note this past spring saying that she wanted to send me a copy of her book Take This Bread: A Radical Conversion. Would I like to receive it? Are you kidding? You BET I would!
I received the book this summer and am still reading it. It’s not that I’m too busy to finish it; it’s just that I don’t want it to end. Sara Miles is such a sister of my heart that I like to read a little bit of her story then put it away for awhile so I can hear her voice again when I need it. After all, it’s not like anything really happens in this book. It’s not a sexy adventure story. It’s just the story of one person’s attempt to deal with God’s inconvenient call, to struggle to accommodate an old and a new world view, to not be too obnoxious about her new passion for Jesus, and to love her partner and child while riding the bucking bronco of that elusive thing called “Christian life.”
Miles writes beautifully - she has an impressive background as a journalist with specialties in Latin American revolutions and politics (some of us remember with fondness her reporting for Out magazine before it became a campy glam-boy mag) — and her story really begins when she ventures into St. Gregory of Nyssa’s Episcopal Church in San Francisco and takes Communion for the first time. An unchurched atheist, Miles writes that “something outrageous and terrifying happened. Jesus happened to me.”
Her description of what happens next will cause anyone who has had a similarly shocking experience with Jesus to hoot with recognition and to cheer aloud her disorientation and her subsequent frantic attempts to intellectualize the whole thing. Oh, girl, I feel you! For all my friends and relatives who wonder how I could have become a Christian, I want to xerox pages 58-61 and say, “Here. I totally can’t explain it. It doesn’t make any sense, but here’s a beautiful description of how it doesn’t make any sense.”
Miles is then drawn into giving herself over to the literal fulfillment of Jesus’ exhortation to feed the hungry. She joins St. Gregory’s* and starts a food pantry. One of the things I love and appreciate best about this memoir is that it isn’t the story of how someone found Jesus and then did something nice and social justice-y about it for awhile before becoming a celebrity speaker on the topic. It’s the story of how someone found Jesus, rolled up her sleeves and went to work feeding the hungry, and is still working with that food pantry today. Rock on, Sara Miles! Thank you for writing so honestly about church life. And kudos to your community and its priests for supporting you in this.
St. Gregory’s food pantry feeds hundreds of families every week. It costs $50 to feed one family for a year.
If everyone reading this post over the next day or two contributes $5 to the PeaceBang blog, we could feed 30 families for a year. If you’d like to contribute to St. Gregory’s through PeaceBang, go to the “Support PeaceBang Blog” and follow the links to PayPal. Let’s see what we can do together. I will match all contributions made today and tomorrow. [Update on Sept. 29: we’re up to $400, gang! Woo hoo! Keep it up!! - PB]
I think it needs to be said that this book is the antidote to the rampant narcissism of another spiritual memoir written by a talented and charismatic writer, Elizabeth Gilbert’s Eat, Love, Pray (which I have ungenerously re-titled Gripe, Brag, Screw). Sara’s book is the good strong soap I needed to cleanse me after being dipped in Ms. Gilbert’s sticky vat of self-absorption, white privilege and obvious addiction to personal crisis and drama. Take This Bread is also full of personal crisis and drama, but since Miles’ focus is on service and not on self, it is far more meaningful to me. It says a lot about our culture that Gilbert’s memoir has been greeted with breathless adoration by thousands and thousands of Americans and has reached best-seller status, while Miles’ book has had a more modest reception. One book is about spirituality at its most individualistic and self-serving, the other is about the demands of religious life following a radical conversion experience. One is Hollywood, the other, Jerusalem.
Take this book and read.
*Sara, I visited St. Gregory’s in August of 2000 and then again two or three years later. I wonder if I may have met you during one of those times? Your face looked so familiar to me on your book jacket…
The second time I attended was the Feast of Mary Magdalene and Donald preached on a trip to China. I was invited to carry one of the –what do you call them? — liturgical umbrellas?
9 Comments »
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI
Leave a comment
Powered by WordPress with Pool theme design by Borja Fernandez.
Entries and comments feeds.
Valid XHTML and CSS. ^Top^

I loved this book. What a treat that she sent you one.
Comment by jacqueline — September 29, 2007 #
What a wonderful book! I recommend it to anyone who will listen.
Comment by Maggie — September 29, 2007 #
Watch out, we’re gonna turn you into an Episcopalian…
I love St. Gregory’s but have a real problem with the liturgical umbrellas. (Speaking of cultural appropriation.) But it is, as the French would say, a detail.
Glad you are enjoying the book!
Comment by Caroline Divine — September 29, 2007 #
Actually, Miz Divine, while I initially found the liturgy at St. Greg’s to be beautiful and inspiring, the second time I went I found it almost unbearably pretentious and smug. Something had changed drastically in the feeling of the congregation and the new vibe felt like, “WE’RE the people you’ve heard about with the ancient and CREATIVE liturgy!” It was distracting and really broke my heart. I guess that’s what I get for idolizing a human institution.
Comment by PeaceBang — September 30, 2007 #
I LOVE your re-title of Gripe, Brag, Screw. And I am going to try to find the wonderful-sounding Sara Miles book
Comment by Gannet Girl — September 30, 2007 #
I think that Sara Miles’s experiences are a testament to the importance of inclusiveness in Christian practice, including open communion.
By the way, Peacebang, I found your reaction to St. Gregory’s interesting. I went to services there a few times. I really wanted to like it so badly–so I gave it several tries, but every time I went I liked it less. But when push came to shove, I realized it wasn’t my cup of tea. It was more High Church than I could tolerate, the lack of a printed program drove me crazy, the a cappella music left me cold, and the elaborate Eucharistic ceremony was too High Christological for a non-Trinitarian like me–and you can’t escape participating in the Eucharist without seeming rude, because everyone stands in a circle and you are just expected to participate. There is so much you are just supposed to know as far as all the rituals go, and no body tells you what it is you need to know. Am I supposed to say “the blood of Christ” to the next person as I hand the cup to them? Hell if I know, but I don’t believe that the wine is the blood of Christ, so I wasn’t about to say it. Once, the person looked at me funny when I just handed the wine to them without saying anything. Oh well.
The dancing is fun, but dancing alone wasn’t enough for me.
Comment by Mystical Seeker — October 1, 2007 #
Your retitling of “eat pray love” gave me a much needed belly laugh today. I totally agree.
I am looking forward to reading Sara Miles’ book soon.
Comment by Madgebaby — October 2, 2007 #
As an Episcopalian, I’m glad you appreciate Sara Miles. But for the life of me, I can’t imagine what you’re thinking about what you say about Elizabeth Gilbert. I’ve not known you to be so off-base in the past about this WONDERFUL book of hers. Sorry you didn’t get it.
Comment by Ann — October 8, 2007 #
Ann, I hope you’ll find my longer review of “Eat, Pray, Love.” Having a negative opinion of something you like doesn’t mean I didn’t “get it.” I wish we could disagree without resorting to condescending put-downs. We could go on forever in that game. I could say, “I’m sorry you didn’t *get* how self-absorbed and toxic that narrative really was.”
But why would I do that? You loved it, and I’m glad you did.
Comment by PeaceBang — October 8, 2007 #