PeaceBang
The manic mind of the minister -- Auntie Mame Meets Cotton Mather. Blogging about Unitarian Universalism, UU Christian spiritual practice, occasional cultural and political ravings, and the inner life of ministry. PeaceBang is the alter ego of a small town pastor serving an historic New England Unitarian Universalist congregation.
Fat and Domestic Abuse
April 12, 2008 on 4:08 pm | In Love Shack, Max Blogging, Photos By PeaceBang, Rants: Sexism |SweetieBang and I have developed a little Saturday morning tradition. I wake up early, walk the dog for a few minutes, then come inside and read for class or church while Greg sleeps in. Then he wakes up, walks the dog for a second time (Max prefers to do his serious business with Doggie Daddy, which is fine with me!), then we go to Weight Watchers where I get weighed in, then we noodle around the mall or somewhere else, and have lunch together. I drive Greg to work and then I go home and work on church stuff or whatever else I need to do.
Lately I’ve been very happy with my Weight Watchers weigh-in, so I tend to do a little “Rocky” arm pumping victory jump when I share my news with him across the room from the scales. He, being a shy guy, gives me a little grin and saves all the “Heeeey, Skinny” comments for when we’re alone (really corny stuff like, “Where’d ya go? Oh, you turned sideways, I didn’t see you!”). He’s very supportive, but it means a lot to me that when we met I was as heavy as I’ve ever been and he was still attracted to me. Hetero men who manage not to have their libidos totally colonized by Madison Avenue and the fashion industry have a special place in my heart. This isn’t to say that all men are necessarily naturally attracted to heavy women, but plenty who are wouldn’t dare act on that attraction for fear of being thought less a man by their peers. As I’ve complained many times in the past, a simple cruise through the personal ads of any American newspaper or on-line dating site will inform even the most casual observer that American men are intensely fat phobic, equating extra pounds with sloth and fair game for ridicule and even demonization. It’s ugly out there for big girls. And no, it seems to matter not one bit if the fat-hating gent in question is himself in possession of a beer gut, flabby or distinctly unhandsome physique, ear hair, foul breath, rampant dandruff or is a self-absorbed, ignorant, unemployed marijuana addict who lives at home at the age of 47. “No fatties need apply!” There is no greater moral crime in America today than to be obese.
With this in mind, it suddenly and with some real horror occurred to Greg and me last weekend that some people probably think he goes with me to Weight Watchers to make sure I’m losing weight, like some abusive control freak boyfriend would do. And Lord forgive us — we laughed our heads off about it. As soon as we leave the Weight Watchers storefront now, we do this whole skit where I say, “Honey, I lost two pounds this week” and he makes a *slap* sound effect and growls, “I thought we said FIVE.” Or he’ll put his arm around my waist, softly grab a handful of flesh and sneer in my ear, “Two pounds? What about this?” And I pretend to cry and say, “I only got to the gym seven times this week! I’m sorry! I’ll do better!” And we laugh like hyenas and get iced coffees.
And yet there are couples who live this way. And I’m sure we all know some of them without knowing that this is going on behind closed doors.
Today we were in breathless hysterics because I lost over 3 lbs. this week (don’t congratulate me for my discipline, I’ve had some sort of flu since Tuesday night) and we decided that, in our skit, before the woman even got the word “three” out of her mouth to announce her great success for the week (”Sweetie, guess what? I lost thr…”), the guy would interrupt by saying, “STILL. FAT.” and totally shut her off.
Of course this is all the funnier to us because Greg is considerably overweight himself and first feared that if he entered the WW building with me, he’d be dragged into a meeting and would be counting points from that moment on. (”C’mon, big guy,” he imagined them saying. “Get on the scale!”).
It really isn’t funny. I know it and so does he. I remember being in my early twenties and starting to get seriously overweight (”seriously” back then being 20 lbs. or so, but in my own eyes I was an enormous blob and desperately insecure about it, although on my good days I felt sexy and curvy and angry that the rest of the world –including women — tended to be so stupid and hateful about women’s bodies). I read Fat Is a Feminist Issue by Susie Orbach and it really opened my eyes to the ways that the diet industry conspires with society’s misogynist impulses to keep women focused on shrinking down to an acceptable size so that they won’t get their teeny tiny brains on other things, like, say, running for president.
When I see slim, fit women at the gym doing their thing, I cheer them on. “Go, sister!” However, when I see them striding into a Weight Watchers meeting and they’re in their early 20’s or maybe not even that old, and they’re thin and beautiful and they’ve joined WW for $9 a week because they’re miserable about the six pounds they’re frantic to lose, I can’t cheer. I want to pull them over and say, “Lovely young woman, take a 45 minute walk three times a week, cut out the sugary beverages, eat three healthy meals a day and nothing in between and you’ll drop that six pounds in no time. Meanwhile, there are so many better things you could be doing with your time than weighing and measuring your food and attending Weight Watchers meetings on a Saturday morning. Whoever told you you should be here, or whatever put it into your head that you need to be a size 2 or 4, let’s do an exorcism for that and you can get out of here and go live large in mind and spirit, ’cause your body is nowhere near it.”
As Auntie Mame said, “Life is a banquet, and most sons-of-bitches are starving to death.” With starvation a reality for so many of the world’s men, women and children, it seems especially important to remind women that there is more important work for us to be doing than achieving conventionally sexy, impossible model proportions that occur naturally in something like 2% of the female population. Health is one thing. My heart and joints are thanking me today for having released 10% of my body fat. Anxiously capitulating to a fat-phobic society that has, at best, a very ambivalent relationship to women’s largeness of being on all levels, is another phenomenon entirely, and not a good one.
If I haven’t made this perfectly clear, let me say to the women reading this that if you are involved in a relationship with a man who viciously shames you about your weight, ridicules your body if you gain a few pounds, objectifies body parts with cruel nicknames, threatens to leave or cheat on you if you don’t lose weight or habitually tears you down, telling you that you’re lucky to have him and that you’re so fat no one else would want you, you are in an abusive relationship. You don’t need to go to Weight Watchers or Jenny Craig or LA Weight Loss Centers or Overeaters Anonymous. You need to call a domestic abuse resource center where you live, your best friend or family member, your minister or priest or other supportive and loving advocate for your health and safety, and make a plan to get out of the relationship. Okay? If you decide to lose weight at some point, that’s up to you.
And I promise that my chubby baboo and I will stop laughing about this issue from now on. We were only laughing because it’s such an atrocious scenario and all too common. Lord have mercy.
(Highly Recommended Natural Weight Loss Method: Beagle Puppy = four or five ten minutes walk per day = hundreds of extra calories expended per month and you won’t even notice it!)
5 Comments »
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI
Leave a comment
Powered by WordPress with Pool theme design by Borja Fernandez.
Entries and comments feeds.
Valid XHTML and CSS. ^Top^
From the perspective of a “thinner” person who attended WW: most of the women in the group I belonged to were about 100 pounds heavier than I was. I was told repeatedly: “You don’t need to be here. You look fine.”
What they didn’t know was that my grandmother, whose physique I inherited, had been obese from her 30s until a few years before she died. This caused her a lot of health problems that eventually led to her engaging in dangerous dieting, which caused more health problems, which led to her death. So there was this on my mind, plus the knowledge that I was becoming careless/thoughtless about my eating, and haphazard about fitness.
I didn’t want to wait until the consequences of excess weight and lack of exercise showed up in my joints, heart, etc. I was 20 pounds above the high end of a healthy BMI, but it was distributed all over my body, versus in one particular so-called “problem” area.
For some people, WW is a treatment; for others it’s a little bit of that, but mostly a form of preventative care. [I hear ya,honey, I really do, but in this case I’m talking about tall, lithesome high school girls in cheerleading jackets with tight tushies the size of bread dishes who come in at 116 lbs. and whose goal weight is 110 lbs. Know what I mean? - PB]
Comment by h sofia — April 12, 2008 #
Someone I know used to make his wife walk 3 miles to the pay phone at the other end of town, regardless of the weather. He knew how long it should take. She would call when she got there and he would read the phone number off the caller I.D. - This went on every day, sometimes at the strangest hours. [Oh Lord. I hope one of these days she just keeps on walking. - PB]
Comment by Michael — April 14, 2008 #
GREAT POST!!!
I used to teach at a girls’ high school, and it frightened me how much they seemed to obsess about their weight. And these were kids who had daily sports, so they were in fine shape for the most part. They rarely seemed to hear when I told them they were beautiful just the way they were. Advertising has not done anything good for women’s self-image.
Comment by Sarah — April 18, 2008 #
I was in an abusive relationship for years. Emotionally and physically abusive. I am also fat, and I have been various degrees of fat my entire adult life. Strangely, in a way quite the opposite of the stereotype, my fat was part of what kept me in my abusive relationship. Not because he told me no-one else would love me fat, but because I came to that conclusion myself. Although he controlled and belittled me about other things, my ex made a point of telling me how much he liked my fat body. And I looked at the world around me and concluded that he was a freak, and I was lucky to have him. What sane person would be attracted to a fat woman?
It took him threatening to kill me to get me to leave the relationship, and since then I’ve had two loving relationships with women who didn’t seem to mind my fat. But I still can’t help thinking no sane person will ever think I’m beautiful. I know I certainly don’t think so myself.
Weight Watchers has helped my smaller but similarly-physiqued sister lose over 40 pounds, and she looks fabulous. I envy her in a way, but I also fear and detest the whole diet industry deeply, and long ago made a feminist political decision not to waste my time and energy trying to be thin.
So I’m in a Catch-22: I neither want to diet or buy into the dominant cultural ideal that I must be thin to be sexy or valuable, nor do I want to be fat.
Alas, I really have no idea what to do about it.
And for the record, I myself am attracted to larger women more so than thin ones.
[N., thanks for writing in. I too loathe the diet industry and even sneer at the cheerleadery Weight Watchers leaders and avoid them whenever possible, going out of my way to find a meeting that has a more mellow, less Corporate Nightmare Fembot doing the presentation. I have written before [check the blog archives under Feminist Rants) about my struggles with fat phobia –internalized and externalized - in our culture, and about my dislike for Overeaters Anonymous. So, I feel ya. As far as finding someone who can love us for who we are, fat and all, I have seen with my own eyes that human beings are remarkably diverse when it comes to What Turns Ya On. There really is someone for everyone, and I believe that we just keep on keeping on, loving ourselves first and best, which is really the hardest part. For me, I was just tired of compulsive overeating and living in fear that I would have a heart attack like my father and be debilitated or dead. I hated feeling that I COULD NOT lose weight and it took a very long time to realize that I will always love food, I don’t intend to stop loving food, but that I could learn to eat differently. I am starting to see the results of some slow changes around my relationship with food. I got a lot of strength for myself when I stopped wasting it on anger at the diet industry and our screwed up, misogynist culture. There may be hidden negatives influencing us, too, that we don’t always want to acknowledge: sometimes people we deeply believe have our best interests at heart and really love us, as you well know. I don’t think it’s any coincidence that as I started seeing the truth about some very hurtful relationships I had with people who, when I was most vulnerable, became condemnatory and abusive, that I started to heal from a lot of things. And it’s also no coincidence that after I stopped trying to be loved by people who really aren’t capable of it, and had the courage to walk away from them, that I met my boyfriend after almost fifteen years of dating losers and abusers. Blessings to you, my friend. - PB]
Comment by Nezuko — April 18, 2008 #
Dear PeaceBang,
I just want you to know that your very very very encouraging example of losing weight with WeightWatchers got me over my fear of “my mother’s WeightWatchers” and got me into a meeting. I joined WW for my 36th birthday and lost 5.5 pounds in the first week!!! I can hardly wait to get to weigh-in THIS week and see what’s different.
Already my knees are happier, my body looks more like itself, and I’m spending less time worrying about the pounds I want to lose. I don’t want to spend that mental energy obsessing - there are people to love and kitties to pet and wedding dresses to build (my specialty)!
Thank you SO MUCH for sharing your experience. I call you “a friend on the internet” when I quote you to other people!
Comment by kate setzer kamphausen — April 23, 2008 #