When Ethical Reflection Becomes Righteous Moralizing: A Black Friday Reflection

Today is Black Friday, that day when millions of Americans head to the mall and millions of other Americans get on large soap boxes to preach against the false gods of materialism and consumerism.

Hey, I got nothing against soap box preaching. I my very own self preached against consumerism and materialism from my pulpit a few weeks ago. My sermon was titled, “Enough Already!”

But I want to talk about the tipping point when a good and righteous cause changes in tone from earnest and thoughtful to smug and shrill. It’s not something you can pinpoint exactly, but it’s a felt shift that happens for me when I notice when social media is packed with rants about the stupidity and badness of those who don’t get on the bandwagon. In other words, the cause about a behavior becomes an attack on the people who engage in the behavior.

In this case, shopping.

I was so taken with Bill McKibben’s lovely little book, Hundred Dollar Holiday: The Case For a More Joyful Christmas several years ago. I read it, recommended it, bought copies for people, read it with two congregations, and changed my holiday habits as a result of it.

It worked. It did its thing. It achieved its purpose. It named a problem and it recommended a solution. In tone and in intent, McKibben’s book was caring, inclusive and creative. It didn’t just want to stop a behavior or to take something away from people, it gave us better ideas that sounded fun and happy things to do.

The liberal moralizing around shopping I’ve seen lately bugs me because it’s high-horsey, judgmental and just plain TRENDY. That really bugs me. Bashing mall-goers this time of year is the social justice arugula of the season: an instant way to earn that enviable aura of moral sophistication or even enlightenment. Meanwhile, a whole lot of folks I see engaging in this conversation drive nice cars, have nice homes, and pretty much already have everything they need. For them to unplug from the Christmas machine isn’t going to a huge sacrifice, as they are regularly able to give themselves and their loved ones the little jump in mood and endorphins that comes at the price of a new sweater or nice dinner out.

There’s a lot of classism in this issue.  ‘Nuff said.

Like I said, this isn’t about me disagreeing with the Buy Nothing Day commitments.  I have gone on record as a preacher expressing concern for the ways that materialism seduces us with false promises and traps us with debt and an oppressive amount of possessions that suffocate us and our planet.

I just think that the issue of consumerism, like every other one we embrace as religious liberals, needs to be treated as a pastoral concern first, and a social, political and environmental one second. The reason is that we cannot reach anyone if we don’t come from a place of solidarity and affection.  If you have never known the thrill of finding a pair of Franco Sarto knee-high boots in your size for 40% off at Nordstrom on Black Friday, remember that those of us who have are not unenlightened sinners in the hands of a retail god, we’re average Americans.

As the church becomes increasingly irrelevant in society, the church has to work harder to understand and connect ourselves to the human experience. When we get into our echo chambers of righteous rhetoric denouncing this or that “ism” (in this case, consumerism), we wind up isolating ourselves from tons of ordinary people who suspect — and I think rightly so — that when we denounce the “ism” we are denouncing the human being who is participating in it.  This accomplishes nothing but to activate defensiveness and to separate us from each other.

Religious liberals are really good at identifying things that people should not do. We’re not always as good at recommending things that we should do instead of the other, bad thing.

To myself and all my colleagues who are preaching against consumerism lately: what program did our congregation offer today, on Black Friday? Did we open our doors and serve hot chocolate and have a game day? How many of us hosted a Make a Gift or crafting workshop for all ages?

If you did offer something like this to be a fun, creative, life-giving alternative to the mall, I’d love to hear about it. Let’s share ideas.

But if we did not – if we merely shook our fingers at shopping and failed to provide emotional support, creative alternatives and a place to do something that would help anxious people feel that they were preparing for a meaningful holiday (something that shopping accomplishes, believe it or not), then we shouldn’t wonder why it is so easy to ignore our fine advice and high ideals.

I’ll see you soon in my Franco Sarto boots. But don’t judge: today in the mall I had great conversations with a half a dozen people and encourage two women to give tickets to cultural events in lieu of gifts. Their kids may groan when they get a day at the MFA with mom instead of the Uggs they wanted, but I hope they’ll start a wonderful new tradition.

 

 

A Love Letter to “Matilda The Musical”

This is long overdue, as I saw “Matilda” on Wednesday, April 17, 2013, right after it opened at the Shubert Theatre on Broadway.

My sister was the one who alerted me to the fact that “Matilda” by Roald Dahl had been made into a musical and who suggested that we go together. I’m the theatre gal in the family and she’s the art gal, so this was a fun role reversal for us. I’m usually the one who has new shows on the radar, but my sister is a fan of Tim Minchin and knew that he had written the score.

Well, Tim Minchin has not just written the score, he has written THE SCORE for me right now. And I want to thank him, and the team of talented people who brought this project to life, because as the drag queens say, it is giving me life.

At the ripe old age of 48, I would have thought myself past the stage of playing an original cast recording over and over until the tape starts to warble and the orchestra sounds like it’s playing underwater. Good thing we’re in an era of new technology, because I have both the London and the new Broadway cast recording (yay!) on frequent rotation. OK, constant rotation.

 

matilda-the-musical_2

“Matilda The Musical” is one of those rare moments in theatre history where original source material, creative team, cast and zeitgeist come together to make something marvelous, magical and deeply moving.

Pardon me, Mr. Minchin, if I get any of your droll lyrics wrong here, as I am quoting from memory.

The show is about children, parents, schools and teachers. It is about families, generational trauma and abuse, and redemption. The most miraculous thing to me about this miraculous show is its ability to shift with total grace and humor between biting mockery of the gospel of every child’s exceptionalism, the stupidity of pop culture (the Kardashians and those who love them should be sent a complimentary copy of Gabriel Ebert and Taylor Trensch moronically celebrating television and the inanities of reality TV in “Telly”) and the comedic aspects of bad parenting (Lesli Margherita, in a kind of blonde Marge Simpson glamour wig, is simultaneously scary and adorable as a brash, neglectful mother without one ounce of maternal instinct) and the depths of the soul.

That may sound a bit much, to claim that “Matilda” addresses the depths of the human soul. It may especially sound so to the composer, Tim Minchin, who is famously and entertainingly atheistic. I hope I won’t offend him by saying that for me, the show’s willingness to spend just as much time on quiet, contemplative moments featuring nothing more spellbinding than a small child telling stories to a rapt librarian (Karen Aldridge as a wonderfully sympathetic Mrs. Phelps) as it does on clever numbers performed by a drill team of preternaturally talented children is what makes it one of the great all-time musicals, and certainly the best I have seen in at least twenty years.

I don’t know how the writers (Minchin and Dennis Kelly, who wrote the book), director (Matthew Warchus, and I’m bowing down to you, sir), brilliant choreographer Peter Darling, design team, and cast managed to channel the complex, slightly macabre, melancholic and outrageous world of Roald Dahl, but they did. They did, and along the way they also managed to achieve something I would never have thought possible, which is to absolutely preserve the integrity of the star character:  a small, bookwormish and sombre little girl who is neither cute, nor winning, nor optimistic. It is impossible not to compare “”Matilda” to another show with a young girl star running right now on Broadway in a successful revival (which I have also seen twice). I love the musical “Annie,” but Matilda is no Annie. Annie is a winning, extroverted little ray of sunshine bringing love to the heart of a big tycoon and to Franklin Delano Roosevelt.

The sun’ll come out tomorrow!

Bet your bottom dollar that tomorrow/there’ll be sun!

Matilda is a smart child who is very much aware that her parents can’t stand her, and who  makes no attempt to be cute about reality. She introduces herself with this hilarious sample of Minchin’s talent for comic poignance:

My mummy says I’m a lousy little worm.

My daddy says I’m a bore.

My mummy says I’m a jumped up little germ/that kids like me should be against the law.

My daddy says I should learn to shut my pie hole/no one likes a smart-mouthed girl like me.

Mum says I’m a good case for population control/Dad says I should watch more TV.

You’ll never catch Matilda tap dancing in the finale. I am sure I am not the only one who found her character revelatory: she is a child who is allowed to face reality head on, to stand up for herself, and to bond with an adult who treats her as an intellectual equal. “Matilda” is radical because it allows a little girl to be angry. It shows a little girl as one who calls out truth in a powerful and demanding way rather than in the culturally-approved dimpling manner we have become used to in female characters.

21879-3314-08matilda-12.5-070

As a woman who was once a serious little girl with precocious reading habits, a difficult and painful home life, and many teachers who became cherished mentors, I relate to Matilda. Her wonderful first act number, “Naughty,” is one of the most delightful character songs I have heard in years (another is Miss Trunchbull’s first act tour de force, “The Hammer”).

I loved “Naughty,” and I was impressed that Minchin would have given such a challenging number to his very young leading ladies (I saw the wonderful Bailey Ryon, who shares the role with three other actresses, as Matilda).  Having assumed that “Naughty” was Matilda’s biggest song, I was wholly unprepared for her second act aria, “Quiet,” a shockingly intense dramatic counterpoint to Matilda’s mother’s raucous declaration of the value of empty flamboyance, “Loud.” While “Naughty” calls on Minchin’s Matilda’s to wrap their mouths around several verses of intricate lyrics coordinated with Peter Darling’s delightful ninja moves, “Quiet” is Matilda’s moment alone in the spotlight, concentrating very hard on blocking out the noisy, emotionally violent and abusive adults around her and trying to explain to us what she is experiencing. It is worth quoting the song in its entirety, as it is a remarkable achievement. The first section is a rushed recitative:

Have you ever wondered, well I have.
About how when I say, say red, for example.
There’s no way of knowing if red
Means the same thing in your head
As red means in my head, when someone says red.

And how if we are travelling at, almost the speed of light
And we’re holding a light
That light will still travel away from us
At the full speed of light, which seems right in a way

But I’m trying to say, I’m not sure
But I wonder if inside my head
I’m not just a bit different from some of my friends
These answers that come into my mind unbidden
These stories delivered to me fully written.

And when everyone shouts like they seem to like shouting
The noise in my head is incredibly loud.
And I just wish they’d stop, my Dad and my Mum.
And the telly and stories would stop just for once.

I’m sorry, I’m not quite explaining it right.
the noise becomes anger and the anger is light
And its burning inside me would usually fade.
But it isn’t today.
And the heat and the shouting.
And my heart is pounding.
And my eyes are burning
And suddenly everything, everything is…

Here, Matilda becomes connected to her telekenetic power and brings us into what she is experiencing:

Quiet
Like silence, but not really silent.
Just that still sort of quiet.
Like the sound of a page being turned in a book.
Or a pause in a walk in the woods.

Quiet
Like silence, but not really silent.
Just that nice kind of quiet.
Like the sound when you lie upside down in your bed.
Just the sound of your heart in your head.

And though the people around me.
Their mouths are still moving.
The words they are forming.
Cannot reach me anymore!

And it is quiet.
And I am warm.
Like I’ve sailed.
Into the eye of the storm.
Well, excuse me Tim Minchin, but for all your atheistic protestations, I would nevertheless like to thank you for putting a child’s mystical experience to music. I think you have written one of the most deeply spiritual musical numbers I have ever heard on the musical theatre stage.

I was a child who had mystical experiences, and I know what I’m talking about. Apparently, Tim Minchin, so do you.  You captured it, you gave it music and words and you gave it to me as a gift that I will always cherish (and hopefully perform myself) and love you for.  So there, with your sarcasm and sexy eyeliner and messy hair and huge heart.

Continue reading “A Love Letter to “Matilda The Musical””

Living Alone

It’s Singles Week or something like that, and the Huffington Post wants to make sure that you think living alone is s silly and juvenile a choice as they apparently do. It allows you to watch whatever you want on television and talk to your shampoo and conditioner while you take really long baths!

A recent census informs us that 27% — almost one third !! — of Americans are living alone. Some of that is due to isolating factors like death and divorce — but amazingly enough, much of that is by choice.

As one who has made that choice, let me lay down for the Huff Post some of the more serious reasons someone who isn’t an Adam Sandler character or Disney princess might choose to walk into an empty home at the end of the every day.

1.  Freedom from emotional violence and abuse.

How many singletons draw a deep sigh of relief and happiness when they turn the key to their door at the end of the day and not have to be confronted with the dysfunctions of an addicted parent or spouse, emotionally unstable, manipulative roommates, or meddling vicious family members? Some of us have had enough of that to last a lifetime. Been there, done that! Hello, beautiful, safe space!

2. Financial clarity.

For those who have ever owned or rented a home with a roomie or partner and had the relationship and the living situation turn suddenly precarious or disastrous because of the fiscal irresponsibility of another person, the expense of living alone seems like a small price to pay to know where you stand at all times.  The bills come in, you know where they are and whether they have been paid. If you can’t afford to live where you live, you are responsible and can do something about it. You’re not going to take someone else down with you, or be taken down.

3. Peace and quiet.

Many human beings just function better and have more to give when they can have a significant amount of silence and tranquility in their lives. I am one of those. As a “psychic sensitivo” and religious professional, I can speak for the need for solitude and silence as a major component of my well-being. I could join a hermitage, I guess, but I am fond of living and working in the regular world.

4. Happiness.

Despite the media image of the desperate single girl or guy or the pathetic loner, a lot of people who live alone are simply happier that way, for all the expected reasons. It is a preference that suits them, and now that the world no longer assumes the coupling off of every adult, they can choose a lifestyle that makes them happy rather than try to conform to society’s expectations.  Remember when gay people decided to do that? This is just part of that same sociological trajectory toward authentic and healthy expression of self. Just because there are so few stories, movies, songs and narratives about happy single people that aren’t yearning, angry or defiant (“I’m Better Off Without You!”) doesn’t mean that millions of single people aren’t grateful and fulfilled in their domestic freedom.

In other words, if you compare the personal narrative of someone who has co-habitated and is profoundly unsuited to that lifestyle to the narrative of a gay person who tried to “live straight” for a time, you’re going to find a lot of similarities. The mockery, condescension, suspicion and repressed envy shown by many folks toward singletons reminds me a lot of homophobia.  It’s an interesting phenomenon.

It may be that the singleton instinct is as innate as homosexuality.  That very likely possibility should stop some of the snide comments of the Huffington Post and the Smug Marrieds at the next office gathering.

5. Freedom To Choose and Maintain Authentic Relationships.

Loneliness is epidemic in America. It plagues single people but it also affects people who are married, living with roommates and living in nuclear families. Loneliness is not about being physically alone, but about being emotionally alone, isolated, misunderstood, unwelcomed, and unsupported. People who live alone get to choose their intimate relationships and friendships, and can thus carefully cultivate closeness with others who actually like them rather than those who happen to be related by blood or real estate contracts. And that’s awesome.

Most of us are looking for love. That quest doesn’t necessarily have anything to do with co-habitation.

6. “Honey, Could You Pick Up A Gallon of Milk?”

Harmony, cooperation and love between roommates and partners or family members is a wonderful thing and certainly makes life better. But for every supportive relationship I know of, there are many more that are strained, disappointing to both partners and that follow a pattern of deceit, blow-up and tenuous reconciliation. The emotional roller coaster is one that many of us make great sacrifices to avoid. We’re so much happier off that ride. Being supportive and supported is a commitment that extends past the front door for any good person.

These are the best housemates a girl could ever have.

20130920_120002